• I don't know if people here read this forum. I hope so.

    So, I'm wondering about the policy on using brackets for indications in the transcripts. I don't know if we should use them or not. Its use is inconsistent in in older episodes, and I've been removing them. But then I noticed that most of the newer episodes have them. So now I don't know how to continue. Personally, I like it best without the brackets (except in the middle of a line, I'd always use it in that case), but I prefer to do as everybody else is doing and keep the same style in all pages. Any ideas or preferences? Is there a standard for this?

    To clarify, I mean this:

    With brackets:

    TRISTAN: Blah blah blah.

    (Tristan jumps)

    MARIK: Blah blah blah.

    Without brackets:

    TRISTAN: Blah blah blah.

    Tristan jumps

    MARIK: Blah blah blah.

    Inside a line:

    TRISTAN: Blah blah blah. (He jumps) Blah blah blah.

      Loading editor
    • I like using square brackets, always. Took that style from wikiquote. Whether to use a new line or the same, depends on timing: if Tristan jumped mid-speech, I'd use the latter. If he stopped talking for a moment, the former.

      I don't know if it counts as a "standard", but Lostpedia uses square brackets too: w:c:lostpedia:Enter_77_transcript. I think you can also find it on some other Wikia wikis.

        Loading editor
    • Wait, square brackets? But, um... I don't think I've seen any transcript in this wiki using that convention. The most popular ones are the two I showed: italics and italics+brackets. I was hoping we'd pick one of those...

      I mean, I could change them all to square brackets, if we decide that that's going to be our next convention; it's not that hard. But nobody's been using it so far, why is that?

      By the way, should I expect more opinions here, more voices? How many active editors are there now? I don't even know. Is there anybody who makes decisions (like this one)?

      I checked the Lostpedia link. It feels really plain. I like this wiki's style more; the bold names and italics make it more visual, easier to read. That said, the type of brackets used makes no difference to me, I'm fine with either one. I just want a consensus, heh.

        Loading editor
    • I don't know, they just seem neater to me. Especially when italicised. I used the style in some transcripts I wrote here, but someone changed it, and personally I don't care that much. And yes, I'd rather keep the bold and italics.

      It's just the three of us, it seems. Go to Special:ListUsers and see. I'm the only admin who looks here semi-regularly. (And I'm seriously thinking about passing the torch to someone else.) Some advertising around would be nice. And there isn't a formal decision-making process, so whatever we agree on this forum might as well be called "official". But if you really want a rubber stamp, I can draw you one.

        Loading editor
    • Oh, I hadn't seen the user list. You're right, there aren't a lot of active users in here.

      Well... I'm going to keep the brackets for now. If we get more opinions later, we'll see.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message